The Frosty Gator Menu (Update 2025)

Introducing The Frosty Gator, a vibrant sports bar in Idaho Falls offering a diverse menu catering to breakfast and brunch lovers. This casual spot prides itself on providing a range of options, from shareables like Spinach & Artichoke Dip and Super Nachos to Gator Ultimate Salads and Gator Faves like Beer Battered Mushrooms and Southern Alligator. Customers rave about the friendly service, clean facilities, and quick meals. The Frosty Gator's unique offerings, like the Gator Gyro and Seafood Platter, showcase their commitment to delivering delicious and filling dishes. With a fun vibe, ample parking, and wheelchair accessibility, this spot is perfect for groups, families, and even late-night cravings. Experience a taste of Idaho at The Frosty Gator and indulge in their delectable offerings.

Shareables

Sidewinder Potato Skins

cheddar cheese, crisp bacon, green onions, and diced tomatoes. served with Mexican sour cream

$11.29

Hummus & Pita Chips

housemade roasted red pepper hummus with house-fried pita wedges and served with crisp, sliced cucumber

$12.49

Spinach & Artichoke Dip

housemade spinach and artichoke dip with house-fried pita wedges

$12.49

Frosty Gator Buffalo Tenders

our homestyle breaded chicken tenders tossed in mild, medium, hot, or ass-in-thetub sauce; served with ranch or bleu cheese dipping sauce

$13.49

Quesadillas

an in-house mixture of southwest veggies, southwest seasoning, black beans, shredded cheddar and monterey jack cheese. served with housemade salsa and Mexican sour cream

$12.49

Zucchini Fries

thick cut and battered zucchini spears, deep fried and served with housemade ranch dressing

$7.89

Veggie Platter

a selection of fresh, hand-cut cucumbers, tomatoes, garden carrots and celery. served with your choice of housemade ranch, chipotle ranch or bleu cheese

$11.29

Super Nachos

generous portion of tri-colored (red, white and blue) tortilla chips smothered in a blend of shredded cheddar and monterey jack cheeses with fresh sliced black olives and sliced jalape os. comes with housemade pico de gallo, guacamole and Mexican sour cream on the side

$12.49

Idaho Nachos

generous portion of sidewinder fries smothered in a blend of shredded cheddar and monterey jack cheeses with fresh sliced black olives and sliced jalape os. comes with housemade pico de gallo, guacamole and Mexican sour cream on the side

$12.49

Frosty Gator Finger Steaks

1/2 lb. of our house-cut finger steaks, handbattered in our house batter and golden fried. served with your choice of honey mustard, ranch, cocktail, chipotle ranch or BBQ dipping sauce

$12.49

Chef Salad

fresh spring mix, sliced cucumbers, tomato, mushrooms, onion, cheddar cheese, croutons, boiled egg, ham and turkey

$12.49

Cranberry Walnut Cobb Salad

fresh spring mix, turkey, bacon, bleu cheese crumbles, walnuts and dried cranberries

$12.49

Caesar Salad

$7.89

Southwest Salad

fresh spring mix, corn, black beans, cheddar cheese, pico de gallo, sour cream, guacamole, grilled steak or chicken in a tortilla bowl with your choice of dressing

$13.59

Black & Bleu Salad

baby spinach, bacon, fresh mushrooms and bleu cheese crumbles tossed in a warm bleu cheese dressing and topped with your choice of blackened steak or chicken

$12.49

Chicken Salad

fresh spring mix with tomato, cucumber, mushrooms, red onions, bacon, boiled egg, and cheddar cheese. served grilled, crispy or buffalo style

$12.49

Gator Ultimate Salads

Gator Faves

Gator Super Jumbo Wings

one dozen of our famous supersized jumbo wings, deep fried and tossed in your choice of one of our housemade wing sauces: mild, medium, hot, or ass-in-the-tub buffalo sauce and served with your choice of housemade ranch

$0.00

Applewood Smoked Wings

one dozen of our super jumbo wings, applewood smoked in-house with your choice of naked, mild, medium, hot, or ass-in-the-tub sauce and a choice of housemade ranch or bleu cheese dressings

$0.00

Beer Battered Mushrooms

fresh medium white mushrooms deep fried to a golden brown in our secret house made beer-batter and served with housemade ranch dressing

$12.49

Chicken Tenders

strips of chicken breast tenderloin deep fried in our secret house made beer-batter with Cajun spices. served with your choice of ranch, bleu cheese, BBQ or honey mustard

$15.89

Gator Gyro

our unique lamb and beef blend served on warm pita bread with lettuce, tomatoes, black olives, feta cheese and our housemade tzatziki

$13.59

Seafood Platter

hand-battered cod, cajun seared salmon, hand-breaded crispy shrimp, choice of side and served with garlic bread

$20.39

Southern Alligator

deep fried golden medallion in housemade beer batter. served with our unique cajun aioli

$14.69

Sauteed Southern Alligator

saut ed in garlic butter with onions, tomatoes and mushrooms and served with a side of garlic bread 13.99 price subject to change due to volatile market,

$15.89

Ultimate Burger

house patty blend or all-beef patty, served on a local artisan bun with your choice of two toppings

$14.69

Buffalo Bleu Burger

house patty, blackened and served on artisan bread, topped with capicola, bleu cheese crumbles and our housemade medium buffalo sauce

$14.69

Buffalo Chicken Tender Sandwich

hand-breaded chicken tenders fried crisp and tossed in mild, medium, hot, or assin- the-tub wing sauce and served on toasted artisan bread with ranch and cheddar cheese

$13.59

All Beef Sliders

Three sliders with lettuce, tomatoes and cheddar cheese, served with your choice of side

$13.59

Cajun Chicken Melt

Cajun seasoned chicken breast, charbroiled and served on Zeppole s artisan bread, topped with avocado, pepper jack cheese and pico de gallo

$13.59

Burgers

Sandwiches/Wraps

Steak Dip

thinly sliced beef tenderloin, marinated in-house and grilled with sliced mushrooms and onions. served on a hoagie roll with melted Swiss and a side of au jus

$13.59

French Dip

applewood smoked brisket, thinly sliced and served on a hoagie roll with grilled onions, grilled, sliced mushrooms, Swiss cheese and creamy horseradish sauce with a side of au jus

$13.59

Philly Cheesesteak

grilled steak or chicken with grilled onions, grilled mixed bell peppers, mushrooms and melted provolone on a hoagie roll

$13.59

Jack Daniels Sandwich

applewood smoked beef brisket or chicken breast glazed in our secret recipe Jack Daniels sauce and served on a hoagie roll

$13.59

Chipotle BLT

crispy bacon, fresh romaine lettuce and sliced tomatoes with chipotle mayo on toasted Zeppole s artisan bread

$13.59

Turkey Avocado

roasted turkey breast, hand-carved, with fresh avocado, mayo, Swiss cheese served on toasted artisan bread

$13.59

Mini Fish Tacos

four mini fish tacos with your choice of either hand-dipped cold water cod, or blackened salmon fillets with housemade jalape o coleslaw, pico de gallo and cilantro-lime sauce

$13.59

Steak Sandwich

sirloin steak cooked to temp, served openfaced with a side of garlic bread

$16.99

Gator Club House

roasted turkey breast, pitt ham, bacon, capicola, Swiss and cheddar cheeses with lettuce, tomato and chipotle mayo on Zeppole s artisan bread

$14.69

Cranberry Turkey Sandwich

grilled turkey breast, lettuce, tomato, red onion, provolone cheese and housemade cranberry-bleu cheese spread on grilled artisan bread

$13.59

Southwest Chicken Wrap

grilled chicken, southwestern vegetables, cheddar cheese and black beans in a chipotle wrap with our own southwestern seasoning

$12.49

Chipotle Turkey Wrap

turkey, bacon, guacamole, and cheddar cheese with lettuce, tomatoes and our own chipotle ranch dressing

$11.29

Blackened Chicken Caesar Wrap

your choice of blackened chicken or salmon with hearts of romaine, tomatoes, parmesan cheese and caesar dressing

$12.49

Build Your Own Grilled Cheese

choose your cheeses from American, cheddar, pepper jack, provolone or Swiss choose your addition (1): ham, turkey, bacon, mushrooms, grilled onions, olives, jalape os, roma tomato, avocado or dill pickles

$12.49

Chicken Tender Basket

our famous beer-battered chicken tenders served with ranch, bleu cheese, honey mustard, chipotle ranch or BBQ sauce

$12.49

Fish Basket

cod fillets hand-dipped in our own beer-batter and deep fried golden brown. served with a lemon wedge and tartar sauce

$12.49

Finger Steak Basket

finger steaks cut in-house and hand-breaded in our own special beer-batter, deep fried golden brown and served with your choice of ranch, bleu cheese, honey mustard, cocktail, BBQ or chipotle ranch sauce

$12.49

Buffalo Tender Basket

our homestyle breaded chicken tenders tossed in mild, medium, hot, or ass-in-the-tub wing sauce and served with ranch, chipotle ranch or bleu cheese dipping sauce and choice of side 10.99

$12.49

Baskets

Sides

Side Salad

$4.59

Side Caesar Salad

$6.79

Cup of Soup of the Day

$4.59

Bowl Soup of Day

$6.79

Basket of Tater Tots

$6.79

Basket of Fries

$6.79

Basket of Tots w/cheese

$7.89

Basket of Fries w/cheese

$7.89

Onion Rings

$6.79

Garlic Bread

$3.39

Garlic Bread w/Cheese

$4.59

Gator Chips

$5.69

Chips & Salsa

$6.79

Chips $ Salsa w/Guac

$9.09

Chips & Salsa w/Nacho Cheese

$9.09

Please Include Silverware

$0.00

Please Include Napkins

$0.00

Takeout Additions